http://www.omnitrace.com/birth-family.html
Adoptee Blog

11/07/07

Unethical Adoption

Posted by : Abby in Adoptee Blog at 03:19 pm , 526 words, 273 views  
Categories: Adoption
This is in reply to comments left here. When a person goes to an unethical doctor and receives crappy care, or when an insurance company is unethical by taking a month’s payment to provide insurance but at every turn they are denying to pay, do we call for all doctors to stop practicing medicine or that all insurance is stopped. Hmmm….how about a school that treats special needs children unethically with the idea that some children do not deserve an education or punish them because they have a disability (which happens all the time) but people are not calling for schools to be closed or education to cease.

People deal with all of these things and get beyond the issues of them being unethical by researching, educating themselves and knowing their options, etc. So why should this not be an important part of adoption? I thought that this blog was so that individuals looking or involved with adoption could learn and possibly see different options.

SPONSOR
   123

When a comment is left implying that practically every adoptee was not voluntarily relinquished, or that all adoptions are from coercion, to blindly believe that every adoption was coerced or to imply it is completely wrong is untrue. This would lead people to believe that adoption as a whole is wrong and bad. Leaving people to wonder why something so bad or corrupt exists, which in my opinion is what people involved with anti-adoption movements do, which this person that left this comment is involved with one in Canada.

When I started foster care I quickly learned that you have to set reachable goals and expectations. You cannot just walk in and provide these children with a safe home and meet their needs and expect that it fixes the problem. Honestly, a lot of the children will always have issues and just have to find a way to deal with them just as we have to learn to deal with things in life by educating ourselves, researching, etc.

Change is slow, and we have to learn to educate ourselves and others about avoiding or seeing the issues or unethical practices. Slowly adoptees are getting access to their birth information going state by state to change this, instead of trying to stop adoption as a whole or trying unrealistically to change the entire system. Instead of spending their time sitting and spinning their wheels, they are taking small steps to change things that when placed together will one day be a major step.

There will always be an unethical lawyer, agency around in the shadows no matter if everything changes for the better in adoption overnight. The only way anybody can protect themselves from ethic problems is by seeking knowledge, researching, seeking all their options, and not taking things at face value without truly knowing the facts for themselves.

As some people have implied that I see myself as an expert with little knownledge, is something that I have never claimed. Nor am I speaking out of anger or bitterness. Sorry, I did not realize that birth mothers have claims to all feelings, thoughts and opinions in adoption.

Photo Credit

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: MamaS [Member] Email
Abby: Just let it roll over you. There are some people who are truly victims of unethical practices and many people who truly believe they are victims. My daughter is one of those. She will tell you that she lost her son only because she did not own a car! She has made herself believe that.
In fact, she was given support from the family. She was given a house, all expenses paid, and spending money for a year. (She did not have a driver's license - having lost it due to poor driving record.) During that year she drank and did drugs and neglected her son. When the courts finally removed him she was given this assignment: TO GET YOUR SON BACK: 1. Attend parenting classes. 2. Attend AA or NA meetings. 3. Get a job. 4. Open a bank account and deposit your paychecks in it. She had six months to do this. She didn't. He gave her 12 more months. Nothing. Then he gave her 12 more months. Not one thing was accomplished. So, her son was TPR'd and adopted by a family member who was fostering.
Her attitude is still: If someone had just given her a car, she could have gotten a job and attended meetings.
(Never mind that in that two year time period she went to jail 3 times for driving without a license! In her world, SHE IS A VICTIM!)
PermalinkPermalink 11/07/07 @ 16:28
Comment from: Lisa [Member] Email · http://guatemala.adoptionblogs.com
Abby,
Your blog yesterday and today were right on the mark in my opinion.
Lisa
PermalinkPermalink 11/07/07 @ 17:05
Comment from: Deb Donatti [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
MamaS, I agree. For some people laying the blame for regretful decisions elsewhere, is so much easier that owning their own responsibility in the matter. It is a coping method, although not a very effective one. IMO the anti-adoption crowd swears by it though.
PermalinkPermalink 11/07/07 @ 18:38
Comment from: jpdakota43 [Member] Email
Yeah - revisionist history and selective retention are rife in the adoption community. I admire your courage. Here's the deal, though. You can't win this battle here. Making salient points using accepted logical forms doesn't get it done. Rational approaches won't work. All the political correctness ever invented isn't respectful enough to the woefully wronged. And I hazard to guess that it won't be long before you are "coached" to use a different approach. This is not the home of the moderate. And since this post will no doubt be removed, I'm fairly comfortable saying this just long enough for a couple of reasonable people to read....
Good for you, Abby. Hang in there.
PermalinkPermalink 11/07/07 @ 20:22
Comment from: miriam [Member] Email · http://www.growingjwards.blogspot.com
It's nice to hear your thoughts as always. I appreciate them even more as any thoughts from me would be blown away more than in any field of discussion I've encountere- even politics!- as presumptuous and insignificant since I'm not part of a triad yet. Once I do adopt I'd be dismissed because I'm on the wrong side of the triad, meaning I've bought the dark agenda and must have perverse ulterior motives or be very stupid. So reading here some things I've thought myself, and from a highly intelligent, thoughtful and openminded writer who happens to be very personally involved in several ways is encouraging.

ps. I've never heard of them removing a post here. Comments, yes, but I haven't seen even some of the more inflammatory posts go down. It seems to me many perspectives are given room to voice opinions.
PermalinkPermalink 11/07/07 @ 22:37
Comment from: jpdakota43 [Member] Email
This post as in my post, not the blog itself.
PermalinkPermalink 11/08/07 @ 06:16
Comment from: Jenna Hatfield [Member] Email · http://birthparents.adoptionblogs.com/
When a doctor practices unethically, you sue. You can't do that in adoption all that often, especially not as a first parent. And so you fight for change so that others may not experience the same thing that you endured.

:)
PermalinkPermalink 11/08/07 @ 11:32
Comment from: Jenna Hatfield [Member] Email · http://birthparents.adoptionblogs.com/
(Or, I should have said, some sue. Some, like our family, aren't big on the lawsuit hub-bub. But, again, I had no option for a lawsuit in our unethical adoption. Okay. I hope that explained enough. Brain is working on sludge speed today.)
PermalinkPermalink 11/08/07 @ 11:34
Comment from: Chromesthesia [Member] Email
Sensible.
We need reforms. REFORMS.
But I wonder what the Anti-adoption people purpose as an alternative.
Orphanages?
Guardianship?
Adoption is here to stay, it is a needed thing in the world, but, we do have to make sure it's honest, ethical and that the kids come first.
That is the problem with the current system, (Especially foster)
Not enough emphasis on the kids.
PermalinkPermalink 11/10/07 @ 19:46
Comment from: ljstauffer [Member] Email
REFORMS=Restoring adoptees rights to their obc and truthful adoption records!

To be denied our heritage is wrong, to be denied because the many abuses of the adoption laws may be unearthed, is wrong, Sealed records can mean a death sentence to an adoptee with no access to accurate, TRUTHFUL family medical history

How are we to know were we are going if we have no idea were we have been?

Why are these simple explanations, only a few I can think of right now, so hard to accept by those who can only complain about how ungrateful some adoptees are to be insulted, and have our feelings discounted by your words.

Read the sorted history of Adoption in the US as it was in the 1920-1970's and afterwards if you still believe we don't need real reforms and a more educated public or that in asking for the TRUTH to be told is anti-adoption at least you have a clearer picture as to why so many adoptees feel as I do.

The true story of Georgia Tann

http://www.babythief.com/
PermalinkPermalink 10/15/08 @ 09:03
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

http://www.omnitrace.com

Misc

Subscribe to Adoptee Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 138